Updated November 2026.
Buying a snowblower vs hiring snow removal comes down to two questions, and neither of them is the price of the machine. Are you at the house every time it snows? And is your driveway short and flat enough that one person with a walk-behind can open it before work? If both answers are yes, buy the snowblower. We mean that. If either answer is no, a seasonal contract is the cheaper way to get through a Rutland County winter, even though the machine looks cheaper in the store.
We have this conversation every October, often with someone who just got our quote and is standing in the hardware store doing math. It is a fair question, and we would rather answer it honestly than lose you in February to a contract you resent.
When a snowblower is the right call
Plenty of in-town houses in Rutland are a good fit for doing it yourself. A short paved drive, a garage close to the road, somewhere to throw the snow, and an owner who lives there full time and does not mind being outside at 6 in the morning. A decent two-stage machine will handle most storms on a drive like that.
If that is you, here is what we would tell you to plan for, because these are the things that end up sending people to us in January anyway:
- The town plow ridge. The hard, wet bank the town truck leaves across the end of your drive is the worst snow you will move all winter. It comes after you have already finished, and a light machine bounces off it.
- The heavy storms. A fluffy 6 inches is easy. A wet 14 inches with rain on top is a two-hour job that stalls a small machine.
- Ice. A snowblower does nothing for the glaze on the steps. You still need salt or sand and someone to spread it.
- The week it will not start. Old gas, a sheared pin, a belt. It always happens on the morning you need it most.
When it is not
The numbers change completely on the properties we spend most of our winter on. Long gravel drives climbing a hill. Turnarounds. Second homes up around Killington where the owner is out of state until Friday night. Up in the mountain towns the season brings 200-plus inches of snow, and a walk-behind on a 400-foot climbing driveway is not a plan, it is a morning gone, every storm, for four months.
And if you are not there, the machine is not there either. Nobody is clearing the drive on Wednesday so the propane truck can get up, or so the house is reachable if something goes wrong. That is the part people forget when they compare the two. A machine is the cheap part. Being the person who has to be up at four is the expensive part.
What a contract actually buys you
A seasonal contract is not just plowing. On ours, we walk the property in October while the ground is still soft and stake the driveway edges, the culverts, the septic lids and the turnaround. We set a trigger depth with you. When the storm reaches it, the truck goes out automatically and you do not call anyone. Walkways and steps get hand-shoveled, the slippery parts get salt or sand, and after the storm passes we come back to push the banks back so the next one has somewhere to go.
That last pass is the one you would have to do yourself with a snowblower, after the storm, on a pile that has already set up. Most homeowners skip it, and by February the drive is a single lane.
The middle ground some people pick
Some full-time owners do both. They keep a small machine for the walkway, the deck and the front steps, and let us handle the driveway. That is a reasonable split, and honestly it is the one we would pick for a lot of in-town houses with a long drive: the job the machine is good at, and none of the jobs it is not.
If you are still not sure which side of the line your property sits on, the details of what we clear are on our snow and ice management page, and what a snow removal service actually clears goes through the list item by item. The one thing we would not do is wait until the first storm to decide. Our routes fill before then, and so does everyone else's.
